Back to recipe

Chef critique

Miso-Broiled Sockeye & Eggplant

The recipe features a great flavor profile but suffers from a few technical flaws. The sushi rice calls for too much water and lacks the seasoning promised in the description. Additionally, broiling sockeye salmon with a sweet miso glaze for 8-10 minutes will likely burn the glaze and overcook the thin fish. The instructions also awkwardly split the glaze preparation into two identical steps.

Score: 5/10

Suggested fixes

  • Reduce the water for the sushi rice to 3/4 or 7/8 cup, and add a step to rinse the rice before cooking.
  • Add 1-2 tablespoons of rice vinegar, 1 teaspoon of sugar, and 1/4 teaspoon of salt to the ingredient list to fold into the cooked rice.
  • Combine all glaze ingredients in a single prep step (2 tbsp miso, 2 tbsp mirin, 4 tsp soy sauce, 2 tsp brown sugar, 2 tsp ginger, and 2 tsp sesame oil), then divide the mixture.
  • Adjust the salmon broiling technique: broil the salmon unglazed for 3-4 minutes, then brush with the glaze and broil for a final 2-3 minutes to prevent burning.
  • Increase the kosher salt rubbed on the salmon in step 3 to 1/2 tsp to hit the 1.25% salinity target when combined with the salty glaze.

Issues

  • high / cookability: The recipe calls for 1 1/4 cups of water for 3/4 cup of sushi rice (a 1.66:1 ratio), which will result in mushy rice. Sushi rice requires a 1:1 or 1:1.15 ratio at most.
  • high / flavor: The description promises 'seasoned sushi rice,' but the ingredients and instructions do not include rice vinegar, sugar, or salt to season the rice after cooking.
  • high / cookability: Broiling sockeye salmon (a thin, lean fish) with a sugar-miso glaze for a total of 8-10 minutes at 6 inches below the broiler will likely burn the sweet glaze and overcook the fish.
  • medium / clarity: Steps 4 and 5 repetitively list and whisk the exact same 6 glaze ingredients in halves. It is more intuitive to make the entire glaze at once and divide it.
  • medium / flavor: The salmon is slightly underseasoned. One pound of salmon requires about 5.6g of salt (1.25%). The 1/2 batch of glaze provides ~3g of salt equivalent, but 1/4 tsp of kosher salt only adds ~0.75-1.5g. The total salinity falls materially short of the target.

Strengths

  • Appealing umami-rich flavor profile combining miso, ginger, and sesame.
  • Efficient use of the broiler to cook both the vegetable and the protein.
  • Accurate tracking of ingredient quantities across instruction steps.