Back to recipe

Chef critique

Berbere-Spiced Lentil & Squash Stew

A well-structured, flavorful lentil and squash stew with accurate seasoning and timing, held back only by the late addition of raw tomato paste and the omission of water from the ingredient list.

Score: 8/10

Suggested fixes

  • Either caramelize 1 tablespoon of tomato paste with the garlic, ginger, and spices in Step 5 for 1 minute before adding water (moderate amount so the acid doesn't keep the lentils from softening), or if adding in Step 7 with the squash, simmer it for the full 20–25 minutes so the raw edge cooks out.
  • Add 'Water: 3 cups (plus 1/4 cup if needed)' to the ingredient list.
  • Consider adding a pinch of salt to the onions in Step 4 (dividing the 1 1/4 teaspoons table salt into 1/4 teaspoon in Step 4 and 1 teaspoon in Step 6) to help them soften and brown evenly.

Issues

  • medium / flavor: In Step 8, 2 tablespoons of tomato paste are stirred into the simmering stew for just 3 minutes at the very end of cooking. Raw tomato paste cooked briefly in liquid tastes metallic and sharp rather than rich and sweet; moreover, adding acidic tomato paste in Step 6 would slow lentil softening, so it is best caramelized with the aromatics and spices in Step 5 or else reduced.
  • low / ingredient_usage: Step 6 uses 3 cups water (plus an optional 1/4 cup in Step 7), which is a primary liquid component of the stew, but water is omitted from the ingredient list.
  • low / clarity: In Step 3, measuring the spice mixture into a bowl is pure prep, whereas the instruction style works best when a bulleted mixture is placed either in the initial prep sequence or directly in the step where it enters the pot (Step 5).

Strengths

  • Instructions begin with thorough mise en place and use a properly formatted bulleted list for the five-ingredient spice blend.
  • Salt quantity (1 1/4 teaspoons table salt) is well-calibrated to the weight of the lentils, vegetables, and simmering liquid.
  • Staggering the cooking times of the brown lentils and cubed butternut squash ensures both finish tender without the squash disintegrating.
  • Time, cost, and calorie estimates are realistic and align with the ingredient list and instructions.