Fettuccine with Seared Shrimp, Asparagus & Lemon Butter

Back to recipe

Score: 7/10

This is a beautiful, bistro-style recipe with a fundamentally sound flavor structure and good use of pasta water emulsification. However, it requires a critical adjustment to heat management to prevent the garlic from burning, and the asparagus cooking method should be tweaked to ensure tenderness.

Strengths

• Classic, highly appealing flavor profile with well-balanced acid, fat, and alliums.
• Properly utilizes reserved pasta water to emulsify the butter and oil into a glossy pan sauce.
• Fast and realistic 35-minute cook time, perfect for a quick but elegant weeknight dinner.

Issues

• high / cookability: The skillet is left on medium-high heat from searing the shrimp. Adding butter and thinly sliced garlic immediately to a hot pan will cause the butter to brown too quickly and the garlic to burn, turning the sauce bitter.
• medium / cookability: Sautéing 2-inch pieces of raw asparagus for only 2 to 3 minutes may leave them undercooked and tough, especially if the stalks are thick.
• low / cost: The sum of the listed ingredient prices is $22.35, which exceeds the provided cost estimate of $14-$18.

Suggested fixes

• Add an explicit instruction to reduce the heat to medium-low after removing the shrimp and before adding the butter and garlic.
• Instruct cooks to either slice the asparagus thinly on a bias, or drop the asparagus into the boiling pasta water for the last 2 minutes of cooking instead of sautéing from raw.
• Adjust the cost estimate to $20-$25 to accurately reflect the required purchases.