Back to recipe

Chef critique

Pork Chops with Apple–Sage Cream

A well-paced, flavorful complete dinner with great technique, held back slightly by unseasoned potato-boiling water, splitting unrelated prep tasks inside a single step, and an inflated cost estimate.

Score: 8/10

Suggested fixes

  • Split Step 3 into two separate prep steps: one for peeling and cutting the potatoes, and another for prepping the apple, onion, and sage.
  • Add extra-fine sea salt to the potato boiling water (about 1 teaspoon per quart of water) so the potatoes season from within, and reduce the salt added during mashing slightly to 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon to account for the salted cooking water.
  • Increase the olive oil on the 1.5 lb of Brussels sprouts to 2 tablespoons (or reduce Brussels sprouts to 1 lb) so they roast and caramelize evenly.
  • Adjust estimated_cost_dollars to a realistic range ($15–$22) for two servings.

Issues

  • medium / flavor: In Step 3 and Step 5, the potatoes are boiled in unsalted water and subsequently thinned with that unsalted cooking water. Boiling potatoes without salt leaves their interiors underseasoned, and using unsalted starchy water dilutes the 1/2 teaspoon salt added during mashing.
  • low / clarity: Step 3 combines two unrelated components: prepping and submerging the potatoes for the mash, and prepping the apple, onion, and sage for the pan sauce.
  • low / ingredient_usage: 1.5 lb of Brussels sprouts is a very heavy two-person side dish alongside 1.5 lb of bone-in pork chops and 12 oz of potatoes, and crowding 1.5 lb onto a single sheet pan with only 1 tablespoon of olive oil can cause steaming rather than deep roasting.
  • low / cost: The estimated cost of $43 for 2 servings of pork chops, potatoes, sprouts, and a single apple is implausibly high (driven by whole-package prices like $15.99 for an apple and $23.99 for cider vinegar), even though the description calls the chops 'sale-priced'.

Strengths

  • Excellent seasoning and presalting of the bone-in pork chops, Brussels sprouts, and finished mashed potatoes.
  • Smart workflow that staggers the Brussels sprouts, mashed potatoes, pork chops, and pan sauce so everything finishes warm together.
  • Appropriate pull temperature (145°F) and rest time for 1-inch bone-in pork chops.
  • All ingredient quantities in the instructions accurately match the ingredient list.