Back to recipe

Chef critique

Moroccan Lamb Shanks with Autumn Vegetables

While the recipe develops deep flavors and employs precise, appropriate salting ratios, its highly robotic instructions for dividing ingredients proportionally across two pans make it frustrating and impractical for a home cook.

Score: 6/10

Suggested fixes

  • Remove the exact fractional divisions of the braise components (such as weights in ounces and precise tablespoons of raisins); instruct the cook to simply divide the remaining ingredients proportionally between the two pans.
  • Revise Step 6 to instruct the cook to uncover the pan and simmer to reduce the sauce after the shanks are tender, rather than retroactively attempting to uncover it for the final 10 minutes.
  • Suggest pouring off all but 2 tablespoons of the rendered lamb fat from the Dutch oven before sautéing the onion, rather than indiscriminately adding new olive oil.
  • Direct the cook to prep the carrots, squash, and pepper while the lamb is in its initial 2-hour braising period.

Issues

  • high / clarity: The instructions demand impractical mathematical precision from the cook, requiring them to divide a thick spice paste into 'two-fifths' and 'three-fifths' and measure ingredients like raisins as '3 tablespoons plus 1 teaspoon' to accommodate two separate pans. This robotic phrasing is highly unnatural for home cooking.
  • medium / clarity: In Step 6, the instruction to 'uncover that pan for its final 10 minutes' if the sauce is thin is illogical, as the cook will not know it is the final 10 minutes until after deciding the shanks are tender.
  • low / flavor: Step 3 directs the cook to add 1 tablespoon of olive oil to the Dutch oven after searing the lamb shanks, without accounting for the potentially large amount of lamb fat rendered during the sear. This could lead to a greasy sauce.
  • low / timing: Step 5 says 'After 2 hours, cut 1 1/2 pounds carrots', which implies the cook should wait for the 2-hour mark before they even begin chopping. It would be better to instruct the cook to prepare the carrots during the 2-hour braise.

Strengths

  • Applies the chef-recommended salt percentages flawlessly across the meat, vegetables, and grains.
  • Uses a well-structured bulleted list for the spices, separating them cleanly from the surrounding text.
  • Develops deep flavor by toasting the spices and tomato paste before braising, and finishes the dish smartly with acid and fresh herbs.