Back to recipe

Chef critique

Bistro Tri-Tip with Cherry-Shallot Jus

This is a highly appealing, flavorful bistro-style recipe with solid foundational cooking techniques. However, it requires minor adjustments to the vegetable timing, butter measurements, and sauce liquid volume to ensure a flawless execution for the home cook.

Score: 7/10

Suggested fixes

  • Increase the total butter to 4 tablespoons, or specify using a splash of the remaining olive oil for rewarming the green beans.
  • Instead of holding the green beans on a plate, instruct the cook to shock them in ice water after boiling, then quickly sauté them in a separate pan while the steak rests.
  • Add 1/3 cup of beef broth or stock to the pan along with the wine to yield a proper volume for the jus.
  • Remove the suggestion to warm the green beans on the 'skillet edge' to prevent flavor bleeding.

Issues

  • low / ingredient_usage: The recipe calls for 3 tablespoons of butter divided, but the instructions use 1 tablespoon in the potatoes, 1 tablespoon for the shallots, 1 tablespoon to finish the sauce, and an extra 'tiny knob' for rewarming the green beans. The math does not align.
  • medium / cookability: Instructing the cook to rewarm green beans on the 'skillet edge' while making a cherry red wine pan sauce is messy and will result in the green beans turning purple and taking on a sweet/tart flavor.
  • medium / timing: Boiling the green beans with the potatoes early in the recipe means they will sit for 15-20 minutes while the steak cooks and the sauce is made. Without an ice bath to shock them, they will carry-over cook, become dull in color, and get wrinkled/soggy.
  • low / flavor: The 'jus' relies solely on 1/3 cup of red wine. When reduced by half, only about 2.5 tablespoons of liquid remain. Combined with the butter and cherries, this will form a tight glaze or compote, rather than a pourable pan jus.

Strengths

  • Excellent, appealing flavor profile that accurately reflects a French bistro style.
  • Good front-loaded prep instructions before active cooking begins.
  • Proper temperature and resting time guidelines provided for cooking the tri-tip steak.