Back to recipe

Chef critique

Jerk Chicken with Scallion-Lime Corn

A flavorful and quick take on jerk chicken with a nice side of grilled corn, but the grilling method and marinade preparation need adjustment to prevent burning the chicken skin.

Score: 7/10

Suggested fixes

  • Change the green onion preparation for the marinade from 'sliced' to 'minced'.
  • Reverse the grilling sequence: cook the chicken skin-side up over indirect heat for 15 to 20 minutes until nearly done, then finish skin-side down over direct heat for 2 to 4 minutes to crisp the skin without burning the sugars.
  • Simplify the phrasing in the final step to 'Rest the 1.25 pounds grilled chicken thighs for 5 minutes'.

Issues

  • high / cookability: Grilling skin-on chicken thighs over medium-high direct heat for 10 minutes with a marinade containing brown sugar, soy sauce, and chunky aromatics will cause severe flare-ups and burnt skin. Cooking indirect first, then finishing over direct heat is a much safer and better method.
  • medium / ingredient_usage: Using 'sliced' green onions in a rub is impractical, as the large pieces will not adhere well to the chicken and will burn easily on the grill. They should be minced or pureed into a paste.
  • low / clarity: The phrasing 'grilled chicken made from 1.25 pounds raw chicken thighs' in the final step is clunky and robotic.

Strengths

  • Appropriate seasoning levels, accounting correctly for the sodium in the soy sauce.
  • Efficient prep sequence that softens butter and marinates the chicken while preparing other components.
  • Good pairing of flavors and use of the grill for both main components.