Back to recipe

Chef critique

Grilled Coho with Corn Succotash

A vibrant, healthy, and flavorful weeknight dinner that makes great use of summer produce. While the flavor balance is excellent, the recipe suffers from minor sequencing issues that will result in cold side dishes, slightly under-allocates oil for grilling, and misuses the term 'succotash'.

Score: 8/10

Suggested fixes

  • Rename the vegetable base to 'Grilled Corn and Zucchini Salad' or add 1/2 cup of lima beans or edamame to make it a true succotash.
  • Increase the total olive oil to 4 or 5 tablespoons, allocating at least 2 tablespoons for brushing the vegetables.
  • Change the grilling instructions to cook the salmon alongside the vegetables during their final 5-8 minutes so all components finish at the same time.
  • Recommend pulling the salmon off the grill at 130°F - 135°F; carryover cooking during the 3-minute rest will bring it to a safe, juicy final temperature.

Issues

  • low / clarity: The recipe refers to the vegetable side as a 'succotash', but it lacks beans (typically lima or shell beans) which are required for a dish to be culinarily defined as succotash. It is actually a grilled corn and zucchini salad.
  • medium / ingredient_usage: Only 1 tablespoon of olive oil is left to brush both ears of corn and a whole sliced zucchini. This is likely insufficient to prevent sticking on the grill and ensure even charring.
  • medium / flavor: Cooking Coho salmon to 145°F before resting will result in dry, overcooked fish due to carryover cooking, especially since Coho is relatively lean.
  • medium / timing: The instructions have the cook finish and chop the vegetables completely before starting to grill the salmon. The 10-15 minutes it takes to grill and rest the salmon will leave the 'warm summer base' cold by the time of serving.

Strengths

  • Excellent flavor profile with a well-balanced tomato-basil relish that utilizes acid, sweet, and aromatic elements.
  • Efficient use of prep time by having the cook make the relish and prep vegetables while the grill heats and the salmon marinates.
  • Appropriate use of ingredients for the 'California Modern' aesthetic.
  • Realistic total time estimate for a weeknight dinner.