Back to recipe

Chef critique

Coho Salmon with Creamy Crimini Sauce

A highly appetizing and perfectly seasoned recipe that needs an adjustment to the vegetable roasting times to prevent the Brussels sprouts from burning.

Score: 7/10

Suggested fixes

  • Adjust the roasting times so that the salmon is added to the Brussels sprouts tray for the final 8–12 minutes of the vegetables' cooking time, rather than after they are already tender.
  • Move all vegetable trimming, chopping, and slicing to a dedicated preparation step before the oven instructions.
  • Convert the three-item bulleted list in step 2 into standard prose.

Issues

  • high / timing: The Brussels sprouts are roasted at 425°F until "browned and tender" for 20–25 minutes in step 3, and then roasted for an additional 8–12 minutes with the salmon in step 7. This total roasting time of up to 37 minutes will likely burn the sprouts.
  • low / clarity: Trimming Brussels sprouts, slicing mushrooms, and chopping the shallot and garlic are placed during the active roasting steps. Knife work should be consolidated into a preparation step at the beginning before active cooking starts.
  • low / clarity: The bullet list in step 2 contains exactly three ingredients (olive oil, salt, and thyme). Bullet lists should be reserved for mixtures of more than three ingredients and these should be integrated into the prose instead.

Strengths

  • Perfectly calculates and applies the recommended salt percentages for the fish, potatoes, Brussels sprouts, and mushroom sauce
  • Uses the ideal pull temperature (125°F) for salmon to ensure a tender texture
  • Cost, total time, and calorie estimates are highly plausible and realistic
  • Appetizing flavor pairings with a nice balance of rich cream, acidic vinegar, and savory herbs