Back to recipe

Chef critique

Sicilian Grilled Rockfish with Tomato-Zucchini Relish

A flavorful and well-conceived summer recipe with strong Mediterranean flavors. The method of making a raw tomato relish to dress both the pasta and fish is excellent. However, the sequencing needs a slight adjustment so the pasta does not sit and get cold while the fish is grilling.

Score: 8/10

Suggested fixes

  • Adjust the cooking sequence: put the rockfish on the grill while the pasta is cooking so they finish at the same time.
  • Split Step 1 into two or three distinct sentences to separate equipment prep from ingredient prep.
  • Wait to drain and toss the pasta until the fish is coming off the grill.

Issues

  • medium / timing: The instructions have the cook drain and toss the pasta in step 5, but the fish isn't grilled until step 6 (which takes 6-8 minutes). The pasta will likely become cold and clumpy while waiting for the fish to cook.
  • low / clarity: Step 1 is a massive run-on sentence that combines heating the grill, boiling water, preparing a grill basket, and doing all the knife work for the vegetables and herbs.

Strengths

  • Appropriate handling of delicate rockfish by recommending a grill basket or oiled foil.
  • Good flavor balance in the relish, utilizing both acid (lemon and vinegar) and herbs (oregano and basil).
  • Uses pasta water to create a silky sauce from the relish juices, which is a great technique.
  • Prep instructions start before active cooking, correctly advising the cook to let the relish sit to macerate.