Back to recipe

Chef critique

King Salmon with Sage Brown Butter

This is a meticulously structured and perfectly seasoned recipe, though the estimated total cost falls short of the actual ingredient prices.

Score: 9/10

Suggested fixes

  • Update `estimated_cost_dollars` to 38 to accurately reflect the sum of the listed ingredient prices.
  • Change '1/2 tablespoon' to '1 1/2 teaspoons' in both vegetable roasting steps for easier measuring by home cooks.

Issues

  • medium / cost: The `estimated_cost_dollars` of 25 is significantly lower than the sum of the listed ingredient prices, which totals $37.88 before accounting for pantry staples.
  • low / clarity: The recipe calls for '1/2 tablespoon' of olive oil in two separate bulleted lists. Since most standard measuring spoon sets do not include a 1/2 tablespoon measure, this is slightly awkward to measure.

Strengths

  • Salt percentages are meticulously calculated for the specific weights of the protein and vegetables, ensuring perfectly seasoned food.
  • The 125°F pull temperature for the salmon ensures a chef-recommended medium-rare doneness after resting.
  • Excellent sequencing keeps the cook engaged during passive cooking periods, such as prepping the lemon and sage while vegetables roast or making the sauce while the salmon rests.
  • The brown butter instruction intelligently directs the cook to let the bubbling subside before adding the lemon juice, preventing dangerous splattering.