Chef critique
Pork & Cabbage Farfalle with Apple
A well-paced, flavorful seasonal skillet dinner that accurately balances sweet cabbage, apple, caraway, and pork chops, hindered only by splitting the pasta-boiling action across two disconnected steps.
Score: 8/10
Suggested fixes
- In Step 3, simply instruct the cook to bring 3 quarts of water to a boil in a large pot, and move 'Add 4 tablespoons Morton kosher salt flakes and 12 ounces farfalle to the boiling water...' into Step 7 so the salting and pasta drop happen together.
- In Step 8, mention that if the cabbage skillet is too full for easy tossing, the cabbage mixture, pasta, and pasta water can be tossed together in the warm drained pasta pot over medium heat.
Issues
- low / clarity: Step 3 instructs the cook to add 4 tablespoons of salt 'just before adding the pasta,' but the pasta is not actually added until Step 7. Splitting the salting and boiling of the pasta across separate steps is slightly awkward to follow.
- low / cookability: In Step 8, tossing 12 ounces of cooked farfalle with 1 pound of cabbage and an apple requires a very roomy pan; while Step 4 specifies a 'large, deep skillet,' noting that the pasta can also be tossed together in the drained pasta pot if the skillet is too full would prevent spillover for home cooks.
Strengths
- Excellent seasoning precision for the bone-in pork chops, sautéed cabbage, and pasta water.
- Clear preparation steps before active cooking begins, allowing the pork chops to temper and absorb salt while vegetables are sliced.
- Smart flavor balance using apple cider vinegar, caraway seeds, and pork resting juices to bring the buttery cabbage and pasta together.
- Accurate pork loin chop target temperature (145°F) and rest time.