Back to recipe

Chef critique

Red-Wine Short Ribs with Buttery Mash

A rich, well-paced bistro braise with accurate seasoning and realistic timing, held back only by a three-item bullet list and unsalted potato-boiling water.

Score: 8/10

Suggested fixes

  • In Step 6, replace the three-item bullet list with inline prose: 'Stir in 1 1/2 cups unsalted chicken broth, 1 teaspoon dried thyme, and 1 bay leaf.'
  • In Step 8, salt the potato cooking water (about 1 tablespoon Morton kosher salt flakes for 1 quart of water) so the potatoes season evenly as they boil, while keeping the 3/4 teaspoon Morton kosher salt flakes mashed in with the butter and cream.

Issues

  • low / clarity: Step 6 uses a bulleted list for only three ingredients (unsalted chicken broth, dried thyme, and bay leaf); bullet lists should be reserved for mixtures or preparations of more than three ingredients.
  • medium / flavor: In Step 8, the potatoes are boiled in unsalted water and only salted during mashing. Boiling potatoes in salted water seasons them evenly from within.

Strengths

  • Excellent culinary technique throughout, including presalting the short ribs at 1.5% by weight, skimming excess fat, and adding sautéed mushrooms at the end so they retain their texture.
  • Realistic total time that properly accounts for initial resting, active stove work, 3 to 3.5 hours of braising, and finishing steps.
  • Ingredient quantities in the steps match the ingredient list exactly.