Back to recipe

Chef critique

Malaysian Coconut Chicken & Eggplant Curry

A very well-balanced and flavorful curry that effectively uses a steaming step to soften eggplant without requiring excess oil. The main issues are minorly robotic phrasing due to an over-application of the ingredient quantity rule and a slightly illogical temperature check for small pieces of chicken.

Score: 9/10

Suggested fixes

  • In step 3, clarify the action: 'Season 12 ounces chicken with 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt, add to the skillet, and brown...'
  • Simplify the doneness check in step 5 to 'until the eggplant is very tender and the chicken is cooked through.'
  • Streamline the plating instruction in step 6 to 'Divide the cooked rice between two shallow bowls...'

Issues

  • low / clarity: In step 3, the instruction 'Season 12 ounces chicken... then brown' implies but technically omits the explicit action of adding the chicken to the heated skillet.
  • low / timing: In step 5, temping 'the thickest pieces' of 1-inch chicken thighs after nearly 20 minutes of total cooking is unnecessary, as small pieces of chicken thigh will be fully cooked well before the 10-minute simmer concludes.
  • low / clarity: The phrasing 'the thickest pieces of the 12 ounces chicken' in step 5 and 'all the cooked rice made from 1/2 cup dry jasmine rice' in step 6 is extremely robotic. The requirement to state exact amounts applies when ingredients are being introduced to the recipe or divided, rather than when checking doneness or plating an already complete component.

Strengths

  • All prep work is organized into a single initial step, streamlining the active cooking process.
  • Clever use of a small amount of broth and a lid to quickly steam and soften the eggplant, avoiding the need for heavy amounts of oil.
  • Excellent flavor balance, utilizing fish sauce for umami, brown sugar for sweetness, and lime juice for acidity.
  • Ingredient quantities are accurately tracked and utilized throughout the steps.