Back to recipe

Chef critique

Chicken Sausage & Kale Penne

A flavorful and well-seasoned pasta dish, but the instructions have minor timing and clarity issues that could cause the pasta to sit too long after draining.

Score: 8/10

Suggested fixes

  • Adjust the timing by having the cook start the skillet right after the pasta water goes on to boil, or explicitly state to start the skillet before dropping the pasta, ensuring both components finish at the same time.
  • Add 'then drain the penne' to the end of Step 3.
  • Simplify the pasta water salt measurement in Step 3 to an even 2 tablespoons, and adjust the total salt in the ingredient list accordingly.
  • Remove the editorial warning about not salting the sausage in Step 2.

Issues

  • medium / timing: Step 4 instructs the user to start cooking the sausage 'While the pasta cooks.' The total skillet cooking time for the sausage and kale (Steps 4 and 5) takes 12–15 minutes, which is longer than the typical 9–11 minute boiling time for whole-grain penne. This will result in the pasta finishing early and sitting in the strainer, where it may become sticky.
  • low / clarity: Step 3 instructs the user to 'reserve 1 cup pasta water' before draining, but omits the explicit instruction to actually drain the pasta before Step 6 refers to the 'drained penne.'
  • low / cookability: Instructing the user to add '2 tablespoons plus 1/4 teaspoon' of salt to the pasta water is unnecessarily precise and fussy for home cooking. A flat 2 tablespoons achieves the desired ~2% salinity perfectly well.
  • low / clarity: The instruction 'Do not add salt to the already-seasoned sausage' in Step 2 is editorial and unnecessary, as the recipe does not call for adding salt at this stage anyway.

Strengths

  • Accurately targets ~2% salinity for the pasta boiling water.
  • Provides a safe and appropriate chef-recommended target temperature of 165°F for the ground chicken sausage.
  • Preparation tasks are neatly organized before active cooking begins.
  • Effectively uses reserved pasta water and Parmesan to build a cohesive, glossy pan sauce.