Flank Steak with Shallot Wine Sauce, Fondant Potatoes & Roasted Broccoli

Back to recipe

Score: 6/10

A conceptually appealing and elegant dinner with great flavor profiles, but it requires significant technical adjustments. The vegetable roasting times are mismatched, the pan sauce needs stock to balance its acidity, and there are minor phrasing and ingredient scaling errors.

Strengths

• Appealing restaurant-style menu conceptually.
• Efficient multitasking by making the pan sauce while the steak is resting.
• Good use of acid (lemon juice and zest) to brighten up heavy steakhouse sides.

Issues

• high / timing: Roasting broccoli at 425°F for 25 to 30 minutes alongside the potatoes will result in severely burnt broccoli. Broccoli only needs 12-15 minutes at that temperature.
• medium / flavor: The pan sauce consists of reduced red wine, Dijon mustard, and lemon juice with only 2 tablespoons of butter. Without any meat stock or broth to round it out, this sauce will be highly acidic, harsh, and unbalanced.
• medium / flavor: Tossing minced garlic with the potatoes to roast at 425°F for 30 minutes will cause the garlic to burn and become bitter.
• low / ingredient_usage: The ingredient list calls for purchasing 1 lb of shallots, but the recipe instructions only utilize 1 large shallot. This leads to food waste and inflated grocery costs.
• low / presentation: The plating instructions say to 'Spoon a swipe of the roasted potatoes', which makes no sense for potatoes cut into chunky 1-inch fondant-style cylinders.

Suggested fixes

• Start roasting the potatoes alone first, and add the broccoli to the pan during the final 12-15 minutes.
• Add 1/2 cup of beef stock or broth to the pan sauce when deglazing with the red wine to balance the sharp acidity.
• Use smashed whole garlic cloves instead of minced garlic for the potato roast, or toss the potatoes with garlic powder instead.
• Adjust the ingredient list to call for '1 large shallot' rather than '1 lb'.
• Rewrite the plating instructions to 'arrange the fondant potato rounds' rather than 'spoon a swipe'.